Japan and China will mark 50 years of diplomatic relations this month with little public celebration, as increasing friction over territorial rivalries and military spending frays ties.
The world’s second and third largest economies are key trading partners and just a few years ago seemed poised for a diplomatic blossoming, with plans for a state visit by Chinese President Xi Jinping.
Since then, ties have soured significantly as Beijing bolsters its military, projects power regionally and beyond, and takes a harder line on disputed territory.
In recent months, Chinese missiles are believed to have fallen within Japan’s exclusive economic zone, and Tokyo has protested what it calls growing aerial and maritime violations.
Japan also regularly complains about Chinese activity around the disputed Tokyo-controlled Senkaku islands, which Beijing claims and calls the Diaoyus.
Read more: Japan, China agree to establish defense hotline
“Chinese ships are loitering for dozens of days in the East China Sea, while an artificial island and a base have already been built in the South China Sea,” said Kenichiro Sasae, head of the Japan Institute of International Affairs.
“That makes us wonder — how much further will China’s ambition go in terms of naval power?” added Sasae, a former ambassador to Washington and vice-minister of foreign affairs.
The war in Ukraine has only deepened the divide, with Japan backing Western allies opposed to Russia’s invasion while Beijing avoids criticising Moscow.
Star Komaki Kurihara promotes the China-Japan cultural exchanges in her career. On the occasion of the 50th anniversary of the normalization of bilateral ties between the two countries, she said the future bond is also "unshakable." pic.twitter.com/pRZQdlRFhW
— Zhang Meifang (@CGMeifangZhang) September 25, 2022
And the conflict has refocused attention on whether China might try to forcibly reunite Taiwan with the mainland, prompting Japan’s Prime Minister Fumio Kishida to warn the Ukraine situation “could be East Asia tomorrow”.
Anxious about China
Beijing and Tokyo normalised relations in a joint communique on September 29, 1972, that officially ended their state of war and saw Japan drop its recognition of Taiwan.
Economic ties grew quickly and steadily, but political relations have been more unstable, weathering a series of crises, including over the disputed Senkaku-Diaoyu islands.
Beijing’s growing power has left Japan “anxious about China”, said Rumi Aoyama, director of the Waseda Institute of Contemporary Chinese Studies.
“Japan sees China’s activities in the Senkaku islands as problematic, and involving a ‘core interest’,” she told AFP.
“But the problem is, China doesn’t understand this Japanese perspective. Instead, it tends to see Japan as just following whatever the US says.”
Read more: Japan, Australia sign treaty to defend against China
Tokyo is a longstanding and key US ally, but it has been expanding its partnerships as a bulwark against Beijing.
It backed a revived “Quad” alliance with Australia, India and the United States, and Kishida in June became Japan’s first leader to attend a NATO summit.
“China is gaining power and confidence, that’s a trend that can’t be ignored,” said Ken Endo, an international politics professor at University of Tokyo and a security expert.
Japan must “consistently state internationally” that changing the status quo by force, whether in Ukraine or Taiwan, is unacceptable.
And he says Tokyo needs a more robust defence capacity, something Kishida and his ruling party have already publicly backed, to show that “it’ll cost a lot if you invade us”.
Trading partners
Japan is reportedly weighing boosting defence spending up to two percent of GDP within five years, from the current one-percent level.
That would represent a sea change in Japan, whose pacifist constitution still limits its military capacity, but a modest increase compared to decades of additional spending by Beijing.
It could also carry its own dangers, stoking regional tensions, if communication with China is not handled carefully, said Sasae.
“Every country has contingency plans, including China, but Japan should make clear that it does not want military confrontation.”
Read more: Japan, U.S. could not stand by if China attacked Taiwan: Former Japanese PM Abe Says
Japan’s brutal occupation of parts of China before and during World War II remains a sore point, with Beijing accusing Tokyo of failing to atone for its past.
Visits by Japanese officials to the Yasukuni shrine that honours war dead — including convicted war criminals — regularly prompt anger from Beijing.
For all the tensions, the two countries remain economically intertwined: China is Japan’s largest trading partner and Japan is China’s second-largest after the United States.
And reports suggest Tokyo could be seeking Xi-Kishida talks in the coming months, online or in person.
Business ties are “a decisive factor in stopping a free fall of the relation”, said Aurelio Insisa, a history professor at the University of Hong Kong and author of a book on Sino-Japanese ties.
But they may not be sufficient to thaw ties.
Read more: EU and Japan team up to counter China’s ‘new Silk Road’
“Beijing’s behaviour in its neighbourhood, and Tokyo’s perceptions of it, are the two main factors capable of changing the current dynamic,” Insisa said.
“I would not bet on any improvement on these two fronts.”
AFP with additional input by GVS News Desk