The debut of Karachi’s Kattar has left the audience without thrilling them, and numerous questions were raised about the purpose and realization of the film. With a length of only 40 minutes, this short film is trying hard to deal with some important ideas, but, in the end, it appears that the absence of a logical plot and the underdeveloped characters are its greatest obstacles.
Kattar Karachi premier today at nuplex #Kinzahashmi #Tahaanjum#Imranashraf#KattarKarachi#nuplex pic.twitter.com/gmftvuB30z
— MI DIGITAL TV (@mi_digital_tv) January 1, 2025
A Flimsy Plot
The film centers around Talha, played by Talha Anjum, who is both the executive producer and lead actor. Talha’s character works in a restaurant and finds himself at odds with a land-grabbing mobster portrayed by Imran Ashraf. However, the film fails to establish why Talha poses any threat to the villain, leaving viewers confused about his motivations. Critics have noted that the storyline is barely fleshed out, with Talha’s only notable action being a brief confrontation with the mobsters—an event that lacks sufficient buildup.
The antagonist, Imran Ashraf, never gets to be a fully developed character, though the viewers expect that the villain should. The film’s effort to bring up a romantic element with Tanya, the character of Kinza Hashmi, on the contrary, is just an unnecessary desensitization, and the audience does not feel any emotional attachment. One watcher said, “There is no reason to love any of the characters, even when they are together.”
Direction and Cinematic Choices
Directed by Abdul Wali Baloch, Kattar Karachi seems very much like a music video; contemporary filmmaking techniques make better use of them. The cinematography does not, however, perform the way it should in most instances, no matter how beautiful it is. Critics argue that the style of the director is seen as the main focus and not the subject areas of the film, which is one of the reasons the film is not that good.
Read More: US Supreme Court Upholds TikTok Ban
Putting aside the fact that it was not done properly, the cut scenes are disjointed, and the narrative sagas still have not been in use. The spectators have voiced frustrations over the quick cuts between scenes that look more like music video parts than a well-told story.
A Mixed Performance
However, at the same time, there is still a small advantage present: what shines through Talha Anjum’s acting. By pretending to be a rapper, he is much like his movie character, and he is a potential actor. Nonetheless, many are convinced that no matter how good he may be, there is still a script that is short on theme and depth.
Imran Ashraf has gotten accolades for his acting in other films, but he gets lost in the production of Kattar Karachi when his character appears to be underdeveloped. Critics have stated that both of the leading actors deserve better material that will allow them to display their skills to their fullest potential, too.
Audience Reactions
Following the negative reception, users mostly expressed their displeasure on various social media platforms; complaints like “I expected so much more from this film” and “What was the point of this story?” are reflective of the general mood of dissatisfaction among the audience.
The film adaptation, which only flirts with half of the concepts of the original materials by the use of magic, is, of course, a disappointment. The film has received an average rating of 2 out of 5 stars from the reps, who pointed out the lack of stimulating content and the failed execution as its main drawbacks. One review went through the point: “The film is a dull time-waste; it only could have been better; it was not the failure.”
A Disheartening Experience
Kattar Karachi is a representation of the obstacles that the film industry of Pakistan is currently facing. Whereas the theme of land grabbing and urban problems tries to be the main focus, the film misses the point because of the weak storyline and unimpressive directing. As cinema-goers relentlessly strive to tell stories that are both meaningful and thrilling, the film comes as a visible example of an ambition not followed through correctly.
Nevertheless, Kattar Karachi is such a communicative force that it can serve as an example to those of us who want to transcend the limitations of the mundane. This film may therefore stand as a potential blunder, warning not only filmmakers but anyone who wants to climb the ladder of the movie industry—this is what you should not do.