Islamophobia remains a persistent issue in the United Kingdom, reflecting deeper societal tensions and political challenges. For British Muslims—many with roots in India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh—the Labour Party has historically been a key ally. However, under Keir Starmer’s leadership, cracks have appeared in this relationship. From controversial stances on international conflicts to internal disputes over discrimination, Labour’s ability to represent and engage with Muslim communities is under increasing scrutiny. We explore Labour’s evolving relationship with British Muslims and its broader implications for society and politics in the UK.
Labour and British Muslims: A Longstanding Relationship
For decades, the Labour Party was the natural political home for British Muslims. During the 1990s and early 2000s, Labour leaders like Tony Blair and Gordon Brown courted the South Asian Muslim vote, addressing issues such as immigration and workplace equality. Policies like the Race Relations (Amendment) Act 2000 were seen as milestones in combating systemic discrimination.
Muslim leaders, particularly from Pakistani and Bangladeshi communities, became instrumental in shaping local politics. Figures such as Lord Nazir Ahmed and Sadiq Khan bridged the gap between Labour’s leadership and grassroots voters, ensuring issues like housing, education, and Islamophobia remained on the agenda.
However, tensions grew during the War on Terror, as Labour’s implementation of the Prevent strategy disproportionately targeted Muslim communities. While Muslim leaders such as Anas Sarwar, a rising figure in Scottish Labour, have called for reform, successive Labour governments have struggled to rebuild trust.
Keir Starmer’s Leadership: A New Era or a Lost Opportunity?
When Keir Starmer became Labour leader in 2020, he promised to restore the party’s electability while addressing discrimination. Yet his tenure has been marred by criticism from Muslim communities.
In October 2024, Starmer’s controversial remarks during the Israel-Hamas conflict—where he defended Israel’s right to withhold power and water from Gaza—sparked outrage. Several Muslim Labour councillors resigned, citing moral disagreements with Starmer’s stance. Apsana Begum, a prominent Bangladeshi-origin MP, criticized the party’s leadership for ignoring grassroots concerns, exacerbating the disillusionment among her constituents in Tower Hamlets.
Polling conducted in early 2024 revealed a 26-point decline in Labour’s support among Muslim voters, with many citing the party’s position on international conflicts and perceived inaction on Islamophobia. George Galloway’s February 2024 by-election victory in Rochdale, driven by Muslim voters disillusioned with Labour, further highlighted the risks of alienating this key demographic.
Labour’s internal dynamics have also faced scrutiny. The suspension of MP Kate Osamor in January 2024, following controversial remarks about the Gaza conflict, underscored the party’s selective approach to disciplining members. Critics argue this inconsistency damages Labour’s reputation as a party committed to anti-racism and inclusivity.
50 UK MPs Call for Immediate Action to Protect Children in Gaza
All the Labour MPs that supported the Gaza ceasefire motion – as 10 frontbenchers resign
Impact on South Asian Muslim Communities
The political alienation of British Muslims has significant consequences, particularly for those with roots in India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh. Communities in areas like Birmingham, Bradford, and Leicester, which have historically supported Labour, now feel increasingly disconnected.
For example, Leicester’s Indian Muslim community found itself caught in the middle of communal tensions during the 2022 riots between Hindu and Muslim groups. Local Labour councillors were criticized for failing to mediate effectively or engage with both sides. This perceived absence of leadership has compounded feelings of neglect among Muslim voters.
In constituencies like Birmingham Hodge Hill, where Pakistani-origin voters form a majority, community leaders have expressed concerns about Labour’s lack of representation for their issues, including housing, education, and Islamophobia.
Tower Hamlets, home to one of the UK’s largest Bangladeshi communities, is another critical example. Apsana Begum’s public struggles with bullying allegations within Labour revealed the internal challenges faced by Muslim representatives. Despite her historic election as the first hijab-wearing MP, her treatment by the party has alienated many of her supporters.
Labour’s Electoral Risks
Labour’s relationship with British Muslims is not only a moral issue but also a political imperative. Muslim voters play a decisive role in numerous constituencies, including marginals that Labour cannot afford to lose.
The resignations of Muslim Labour councillors over Gaza-related policies have weakened Labour’s control in key local councils. This trend threatens the party’s ability to mobilize grassroots support in urban areas. Furthermore, the rise of alternative candidates, such as George Galloway, demonstrates the electoral risks of alienating disillusioned Muslim voters.
Pro-Gaza candidates dent Labour’s UK election victory
Rebuilding Trust and Addressing Islamophobia
For Labour to rebuild its relationship with British Muslims, it must go beyond symbolic gestures. Starmer’s recent consideration of an Islamophobia law, while a step in the right direction, has been criticized as too little, too late. Community leaders have called for substantive reforms, including:
1.Overhauling the Prevent Strategy: Ensuring it no longer disproportionately targets Muslim communities.
2.Addressing Internal Islamophobia: Implementing mandatory training and creating a transparent process for handling complaints.
3.Empowering Local Leaders: Figures like Anas Sarwar and Apsana Begum can play a critical role in reconnecting Labour with grassroots voters.
4.Engaging with International Issues: Labour’s position on conflicts like Palestine must reflect the values of justice and human rights, resonating with its Muslim supporters.
Labour at a Crossroads
Keir Starmer’s Labour Party faces a critical moment in its relationship with British Muslims. As a community historically aligned with Labour, Muslims from South Asian backgrounds have long contributed to the party’s success in urban centers. However, recent controversies and perceived neglect risk fracturing this alliance.
For Labour, addressing Islamophobia and engaging meaningfully with Muslim communities is not just about votes—it’s about reaffirming its identity as a party of inclusivity and justice. If Starmer can meet this challenge, he may not only secure a vital voter base but also strengthen Labour’s moral and political standing in an increasingly polarized Britain.
Musk accused of using young girls’ abuse in the UK as a political weapon against Starmer