As internet users across Pakistan experience significant slowdowns, the Pakistan Software Houses Association (P@SHA) has raised concerns over the government’s lack of communication regarding the recent installation of a national internet firewall. Speaking on a television program, P@SHA’s Senior Vice Chairman, Ali Ihsan, expressed frustration at being “kept out of the loop” on such a critical issue, emphasizing the association’s willingness to collaborate with the government to mitigate the adverse effects of this new system. The firewall, designed to filter and block unwanted content, has been linked to the current internet disruptions, which are affecting millions of users.
The firewall, which employs keyword filtering and IP address tracking, is intended to regulate content on social media platforms such as Facebook, YouTube, and X (formerly Twitter). Additionally, the government is preparing to monitor and possibly restrict the use of Virtual Private Networks (VPNs), which could further contribute to the internet slowdown. Despite these concerns, government officials have denied that the firewall is responsible for the disruptions, attributing them instead to the use of VPNs. However, Ihsan refuted this claim, pointing out that no issues had arisen in the past decade when P@SHA was consulted on similar matters.
Economic Impact and Industry Response
The implementation of the firewall has had a severe impact on Pakistan’s IT industry, with P@SHA estimating losses of up to $300 million. Ihsan highlighted that major Information Technology companies have reported a 40% decline in their Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) services due to the internet slowdown. One leading healthcare company, with an estimated $50 million business in Pakistan, experienced a week-long disruption in its 200 communication lines, resulting in significant financial losses. The association has warned that if the situation is not addressed, it could lead to a mass exodus of IT companies from Pakistan, further damaging the economy.
Read More: ATMs NOT Under Cyber Threat, Clarifies 1Link
The Pakistan Freelancers Association (PAFLA) also voiced its concerns, stating that 2.3 million freelancers in the country are struggling to meet client deadlines due to the internet disruptions. PAFLA’s CEO, Tufail Ahmed Khan, warned that Pakistan’s global reputation could suffer, leading to a potential downgrade in the country’s rating among international clients. With the IT sector contributing $298 million in exports in June 2024 alone, any continued disruptions could have long-term repercussions for the nation’s economy.
Government Stance and Industry Recommendations
Despite the growing concerns, the Pakistani government has maintained that the firewall is necessary to protect national security and prevent the spread of anti-state propaganda. The Minister of State for Information Technology, Shaza Khawaja, has repeatedly stated that the firewall is not intended for censorship but rather to safeguard government networks from cyber threats. However, the lack of transparency and consultation with industry stakeholders has led to widespread distrust among internet users and global IT clients.
P@SHA has called for an immediate halt to the firewall’s implementation and urged the government to engage in dialogue with the IT industry to develop a more effective cybersecurity framework. Ihsan suggested that IT businesses be “whitelisted” and excluded from the firewall’s filtering process, as their identification is already tracked through official records. He also emphasized the need for a more measured approach to integrating new technology, warning that the current system’s shortcomings could prevent a swift resolution to the ongoing disruptions.
Collaboration and Growth in IT
In light of these challenges, there is a growing consensus within Pakistan’s IT sector that closer collaboration between the government and industry stakeholders is essential for maintaining the country’s technological growth. The recent surge in IT exports, which reached $3.2 billion in the fiscal year ending June 2024, underscores the sector’s potential as a key driver of economic growth. However, continued success will depend on the government’s ability to balance national security concerns with the needs of the industry.
P@SHA has expressed its commitment to supporting the government in finding solutions that protect both national interests and the viability of Pakistan’s burgeoning tech sector. By fostering open communication and cooperation, the country can navigate these challenges and continue to build a resilient digital economy that benefits all stakeholders.