The debate between compact hatchbacks and sedans has long existed, with the Volkswagen Golf often being held up as the epitome of a functional hatchback. However, when it comes to cargo space, hatchbacks actually have less room than their sedan counterparts, despite having larger on-paper cargo volumes. This is due to the fact that hatchback cargo volumes are measured to the roof, which is not practical for storing bags.
The same can be said for the Volkswagen GTI and Golf R, which have a listed cargo volume of 19.9 cubic feet. However, this measurement includes the space between the back seat and tailgate, which is not particularly useful for storing bags due to its triangular shape. In comparison, the Jetta sedan has a cargo volume of 14.1 cubic feet.
The Honda Civic Hatchback, which serves as the basis for the high-performance Civic Type R, fares better in terms of cargo space. It can fit the four largest bags under its side-to-side roll-out cargo cover, with the option of loading above the cover line to fit all bags. The sedan version of the Civic also provides more space for luggage.
The Mazda3 hatchback can also accommodate the four largest bags under its cargo cover, but interestingly, removing the cover does not make a significant difference in cargo space. The sedan version of the Mazda3 offers even more length in the trunk, making it a better option for carrying luggage.
The Subaru Impreza/Crosstrek falls somewhere in between, with the ability to fit a varying number of bags depending on whether the roll-out cargo cover is in place or removed. Without the cover, it can carry all six bags, placing it ahead of the Golf in terms of cargo space.
Overall, while the Golf may not offer the most practical cargo space among compact hatchbacks, it is worth noting that the Golf wagon still exists in Europe, offering more storage capacity than its hatchback counterpart. Ultimately, the choice between a hatchback and a sedan for carrying luggage depends on individual preferences and needs.