The Audi A2 and Honda Insight, both celebrating their 25th birthdays this year, were once seen as the future of efficient and eco-friendly motoring. However, despite their innovative design and advanced technology, these vehicles failed to gain traction in the market and were eventually discontinued. Today, with a greater focus on conserving resources and reducing costs, these fuel-efficient models are more relevant than ever.
Design and Dimensions:
The Honda Insight and Audi A2 may have different appearances, but they share a common goal of minimizing weight and drag to maximize fuel efficiency. The Honda Insight’s aerodynamic design, with faired-in rear wheel arches and a low drag coefficient of 0.25, stands out even among today’s SUV-dominated landscape. On the other hand, the Audi A2, with its narrow and tall profile, features a Cd figure between 0.25 and 0.29, offering impressive aerodynamic performance.
Interior:
The Audi A2’s interior continues to feel modern and upmarket, with an elegantly logical dashboard layout and ample rear-seat space. Its packaging ingenuity is reminiscent of the original Mini. In contrast, the Honda Insight’s interior has not aged well, with cheap plastic trim and outdated switchgear. However, the Insight’s digital instrument cluster and comfortable driving position still evoke a sense of nostalgia.
Powertrain and Performance:
The Audi A2’s 1.4-liter TDI engine, though dated, delivers impressive fuel efficiency with a combined cycle rating of 65.7mpg. Its lightweight construction and low mass contribute to its deceptively quick acceleration and refined driving experience. The Honda Insight, powered by a hybrid system called Integrated Motor Assist (IMA), offers a combined output of 76bhp and remarkable fuel savings. With returns of over 100mpg recorded by some owners, the Insight outshines the Audi in terms of fuel economy.
Driving Dynamics:
Despite their differences, both the Audi A2 and Honda Insight provide an enjoyable driving experience. The lightweight nature of these vehicles showcases the benefits of minimal mass, allowing for agile handling and impressive grip. The Audi A2 feels more dynamic, responding eagerly to careful driving and offering warm-hatch levels of performance. The Honda Insight, though not as keen to be thrown around, responds crisply and accurately, allowing for precise cornering and maintaining momentum.
Verdict:
The Honda Insight and Audi A2 were commercial failures when they were first released. The Insight, designed as a niche product to demonstrate Honda’s hybrid technology, found a cult following in North America but struggled to gain traction in Europe. The Audi A2, intended as a high-volume competitor to the Mercedes-Benz A-Class, was outsold and resulted in significant financial losses for Audi. However, both vehicles remain relevant today and showcase the optimism and risk-taking spirit of the 1990s automotive industry. With their fuel efficiency and lightweight construction, these models would still be competitive in today’s market.
