The debate between the future prospects of degree holders versus influencers in Pakistan is a complex one, reflecting broader global trends influenced by technological, economic, and social factors. Each group has distinct pathways and opportunities shaped by different aspects of the modern landscape.
Degree holders in Pakistan traditionally pursue careers in established fields such as medicine, engineering, law, and business. These professions are highly respected and often associated with stable and secure job prospects. In a society where educational qualifications are seen as essential for upward mobility and social respect, degree holders are viewed as having a strong foundation for long-term career growth. Furthermore, professionals in these fields have the potential for professional development, gaining expertise and recognition in their respective domains, which can lead to significant contributions to society and personal fulfillment.
Read more: Instagram influencer sentenced to 7 years for $8M crypto fraud
On the other hand, influencers represent a new wave of career opportunities brought about by the digital age. With the rise of social media platforms, influencers can leverage their personal brand to reach large audiences, monetizing their content through advertisements, sponsorships, and partnerships. This career path offers flexibility, creativity, and the potential for substantial financial rewards. Influencers can achieve rapid fame and influence, often surpassing traditional media in terms of reach and impact. However, this path is also fraught with challenges, including the need for constant content creation, maintaining relevance, and dealing with public scrutiny and volatility in income.
The future for degree holders appears to be more secure and structured, offering clear pathways to career advancement and societal respect. They benefit from institutional support and a network of professional opportunities that can provide stability and growth. In contrast, influencers have the potential for quick success and significant financial gain but face a more uncertain and dynamic landscape. Their success often hinges on their ability to continuously engage their audience and adapt to changing trends and algorithms on social media platforms.
Read more: Houthi Influencer Urges Followers to Prioritize Palestine Cause Over His Looks
Influencers in Pakistan, much like in many parts of the world, have become prominent figures in the digital landscape. They hold considerable sway over their followers, shaping opinions, trends, and consumer behavior. However, this rise to prominence has not come without its share of criticism and backlash. The reasons behind the disdain for influencers in Pakistan are multifaceted and rooted in cultural, social, and economic contexts.
Perceived Inauthenticity and Lack of Sincerity
One of the primary reasons for the dislike towards influencers in Pakistan is the perceived inauthenticity of their content. Many influencers are accused of promoting products and lifestyles that they do not genuinely endorse. This lack of sincerity is often evident when influencers promote a wide range of products, from beauty creams to financial services, sometimes within a short span of time. Followers can quickly pick up on these inconsistencies, leading to a loss of trust. When an influencer’s primary motivation is seen as financial gain rather than genuine interest or passion, their credibility takes a hit.
Commercialization and Over-Promotion
The commercialization of influencer content is another significant factor contributing to their negative perception. Social media platforms are inundated with sponsored posts, paid partnerships, and advertisements. While monetization is a legitimate aspect of being an influencer, the constant barrage of promotional content can be overwhelming and annoying for followers. This excessive promotion creates a sense that influencers are merely vehicles for advertising rather than creators of valuable or entertaining content. The relentless focus on commercial gain can make followers feel exploited, as their engagement is turned into a commodity.
Disconnect from the Average Pakistani
Influencers often portray a lifestyle that is far removed from the realities of the average Pakistani. The lavish vacations, high-end fashion, and luxury goods showcased by many influencers can create a sense of envy and resentment among their followers. In a country where a significant portion of the population struggles with economic challenges, the flaunting of wealth and privilege by influencers can be particularly jarring. This disconnect can lead to a perception that influencers are out of touch with the everyday struggles of their audience, further alienating them.
Substance and Value of Content
The substance and value of the content produced by influencers are also points of contention. Critics argue that much of the content is superficial, focusing on aesthetics rather than meaningful or thought-provoking material. This criticism is particularly relevant in a cultural context where there is a high value placed on education, intellectualism, and social contributions. Influencers who are seen as prioritizing style over substance are often dismissed as frivolous and unworthy of the attention and rewards they receive.
Perception of Easy Success
The perception that influencers achieve success with minimal effort is another reason for the disdain they face. Many people believe that becoming an influencer requires little more than good looks and a knack for self-promotion. This perception undermines the hard work and strategy that often goes into building and maintaining a personal brand. However, the notion that influencers earn substantial income for seemingly effortless activities can breed resentment, especially among those who feel they work harder for less recognition and financial reward.
Ethical Concerns and Accountability
Ethical concerns and a lack of accountability also contribute to the negative perception of influencers. Instances of misleading advertisements, promoting potentially harmful products, or engaging in deceptive practices have tainted the reputation of the influencer industry. Unlike traditional media, where there are regulatory bodies and standards, social media is often seen as a Wild West with few checks and balances. This lack of regulation means that influencers can operate with relative impunity, which can lead to unethical behavior that erodes public trust.
Impact on Youth and Cultural Values
The impact of influencers on the youth and cultural values is another significant concern. Influencers often set trends and norms that young people aspire to follow. This can lead to the adoption of values and behaviors that are at odds with traditional or cultural norms. For instance, the emphasis on physical appearance, materialism, and instant gratification promoted by some influencers can clash with values of modesty, hard work, and community. Parents and older generations, in particular, may view influencers as negative role models who contribute to the erosion of cultural values and societal norms.
Envy and Celebrity Culture
Envy and the nature of celebrity culture also play a role in the dislike of influencers. The rise of social media has democratized fame, allowing ordinary individuals to achieve celebrity status. This shift can create jealousy and resentment, as people may feel that influencers have not “earned” their fame in the traditional sense. The constant visibility and curated perfection of influencers’ lives can also trigger feelings of inadequacy and comparison among followers, leading to negative sentiments.
Navigating the Digital Landscape
The digital landscape in Pakistan, like elsewhere, is constantly evolving. Influencers who fail to adapt to changing trends, platform algorithms, or audience expectations can quickly fall out of favor. The fast-paced nature of social media means that influencers must continually innovate and remain relevant. Those who cannot keep up may find themselves facing criticism and declining engagement.
Balancing Act
Despite these challenges, it is essential to recognize that not all influencers are viewed negatively. Many influencers are admired for their authenticity, creativity, and positive impact. Influencers who engage with their audience in meaningful ways, contribute to social causes, and use their platform responsibly often enjoy a loyal following and respect. The key to maintaining a positive image lies in balancing commercial interests with genuine engagement and contributions to society.
In conclusion, the disdain towards influencers in Pakistan is rooted in a combination of perceived inauthenticity, excessive commercialization, disconnect from average lifestyles, lack of substantive content, and ethical concerns. These factors, combined with the impact on youth and cultural values, contribute to the negative perception of influencers. However, it is important to note that this sentiment is not universal, and many influencers who navigate these challenges effectively continue to thrive and be respected in the digital landscape.
The author is a research associate and sub-editor at GVS. She has previously worked with Express-News Islamabad. She can be reached at az.aeliya@gmail.com. The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Global Village Space’s editorial policy.